top of page

Order a Customized Cake!

Since this isn't a walk in bakery, I only take preorders.

I create edible art in the forms of cakes, cupcakes and sugar cookies! It's what I love doing best. My cakes are unique and customized to exactly what YOU want. I love diving into your desires for your event and coming up with the perfect cake to match. 


I'd be happy to answer any (and all!) your questions and guide you through the order and cake design process. Don't need something super fancy? Order on the go and don't worry about detailed quotes!

But sometimes that epic, customized cake is exactly what you need to bring your event to the next level.

Below you'll find a general price range for a variety of cakes, as well as a complete flavor menu with which you can mix and match to create the cakes of your dreams!

Custom Cakes​
Single tier starts at $3.50 per serving
Multi tiered cakes start at $3.75 per serving.

3D carved varies based on difficulty and design
Fresh fruit, special fillings/flavors, fondant, and detailed designs will be additional charges.

Each custom cake requires its own special quote.

rose gold wedding cake


You can order a basic dozen on the go or get specialty cupcakes from the flavors below.

Standard price for 1 dozen Specialty Flavored cupcakes is $27

Price can vary depending on style and complexity of the cupcakes. If you have a specific design in mind for your party or event, please email to get a custom quote.

Teddy bear holds up cake

Wedding Cakes

Each order must be custom quoted due to servings and complexity, so please send me an email at to get this process started.

Pricing depends on serving sizes, number of tiers and the complexity of the cake design.

To get an accurate quote, please include the date of your ceremony, estimated amount of servings needed and the look or style you would like for your cake.

gourmet cupcakes



Vanilla Cake

Chocolate Cake




Apple Caramel

Chocolate Ganache

Lemon Curd


American Buttercream

Chocolate Frosting


Apple Cake

Coconut Cake

Carrot Cake

Hummingbird Cake

Strawberry Cake

Lemon Blueberry


Peanut Butter Frosting

Italian Meringue Frosting

Divinity Frosting (paired with coconut cake)

Cream Cheese Frosting

German Chocolate Cake

All of my desserts are made to order, so please place your order at least 1-2 weeks in advance. It is not uncommon for busy seasons to book up weeks and sometimes months in advance.

If you have your heart set on a cake from I Caked It, make sure to place a deposit as soon as you have a date set for your event.


A 50% deposit is required at the time of booking to reserve your order. No orders are reserved without a deposit. All deposits and payments are nonrefundable but are transferable to another date depending on availability and if the order has been started.


Wedding and large event orders must be paid in full one week before the date.


Trudi S.

I was just thrilled with the beautiful birthday cake Anna made for me! The flowers were so perfectly made that they could have been real and tasted so sweet. The cake itself was so delicious too. I encourage you to order cakes and cupcakes from Anna.

Jennifer V.

Yummy cookies with A+++ customer service! I contacted Anna on fairly short notice because the person I normally use for personalized cookies was unavailable. The cookies tasted better than cookies that I've ordered elsewhere because there wasn't a mountain of royal icing on top of them. On top of that, Anna provided excellent communication and graciously worked with me when I forgot to pick up at our scheduled time. Highly recommend!!

Les G.

The best part was that the cake tasted amazing . I highly recommend "I Caked It" for any custom cake. Whatever the project Anna will ace it. Five stars!
bottom of page